Your capital is at risk. Other fees apply. Sponsored by eToro — we may earn commission. #ad
Use code . Referral link — we receive £50 bill credit if you join.
First Time Buyer ISA vs Lifetime ISA
A new first-home ISA arrives in 2029, and the Lifetime ISA rules changed in October 2026. Here is what each one pays, what it costs to withdraw, and which one fits your deposit.
15 November 2026 · Money Meister · 5 min read
On this page
The Short Answer
If you are under 40 and buying before April 2029, the Lifetime ISA is usually the better choice. The bonus is paid into the account each year, so it can grow with your savings.
The First Time Buyer ISA launches on 6 April 2029. It has no upper age limit, no withdrawal charge and a £20,000 lifetime bonus cap. It is the better fit if you are over 40, unsure when you will buy, or want penalty-free access. You can hold both, but you can only pay into one in a tax year.
What Is the First Time Buyer ISA?
The First Time Buyer ISA was confirmed in the Autumn Budget 2026. It is designed to replace the Lifetime ISA for first-home saving, but it does not open until 6 April 2029.
- Annual limit: £4,000.
- Government bonus: 25%, capped at £20,000 over the life of the account.
- Property cap: £450,000.
- Age limit: none.
- Withdrawal charge: none.
- Bonus timing: paid when you buy, not monthly.
The bonus is paid at the point of purchase. That means it does not earn interest or investment growth while it sits in the account, unlike the Lifetime ISA bonus, which is paid monthly.
What Is the Lifetime ISA?
The Lifetime ISA is available now. You can open one between 18 and 39, save up to £4,000 a year, and receive a 25% government bonus up to £1,000 a year. The bonus is paid into the account every month.
You can use the money to buy a first home worth up to £450,000, or take it from age 60 for retirement. If you withdraw for any other reason, the standard charge is 25% of the amount withdrawn.
The Lifetime ISA is not being closed. Existing accounts stay open, and new savers aged 18 to 39 can still open one.
Side by Side
| Feature | First Time Buyer ISA | Lifetime ISA |
|---|---|---|
| Available | From 6 April 2029 | Now |
| Who can open | No upper age limit | Age 18 to 39 |
| Annual limit | £4,000 | £4,000 |
| Bonus rate | 25% | 25% |
| Bonus cap | £20,000 over the account life | £1,000 a year, about £32,000 total |
| When the bonus is paid | At purchase | Monthly |
| Property cap | £450,000 | £450,000 |
| Withdrawal charge | None | 25% for non-qualifying withdrawals |
| Retirement use | No, first home only | Yes, from age 60 |
Both accounts count towards your £20,000 annual ISA allowance. You can hold both, but you can only pay into one of them in the same tax year.
The October 2026 Lifetime ISA Change
Before 29 October 2026, if you used Lifetime ISA money to buy a home above £450,000, the 25% withdrawal charge could take part of your own savings as well as the government bonus.
From that date, you can withdraw the money and get back at least what you paid in. The 25% charge no longer applies in that situation. You still lose the government bonus, so the account does not give you free money for a home above the cap.
The cap still matters
The £450,000 property cap has not changed. The change only makes the exit less painful if you buy above it. If you are targeting a home near the cap, check the price before you rely on the bonus.
£20,000 Example: Five Years of Saving
Suppose you save £4,000 a year for five years. That is £20,000 of your own money. Both accounts add a 25% bonus, but the timing differs.
| Account | Your contributions | Government bonus | Total before growth |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lifetime ISA | £20,000 | £5,000 | £25,000 |
| First Time Buyer ISA | £20,000 | £5,000 | £25,000 |
The difference is growth. The Lifetime ISA bonus is paid monthly, so it can earn interest or investment returns for the rest of the time you save. The First Time Buyer ISA bonus arrives at purchase, so it does not grow before you buy. On a cash ISA at 4%, that timing difference is worth a few hundred pounds over five years.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose the Lifetime ISA if you...
- Are aged 18 to 39
- Will buy before April 2029
- Want the bonus paid monthly and invested
- May use the money for retirement at 60
- Already have a LISA and are happy with it
Choose the First Time Buyer ISA if you...
- Are over 40
- Are not sure when you will buy
- Want no withdrawal charge
- Will buy after April 2029
- Want a simple first-home account without age rules
If you are under 40 and buying in the next few years, do not wait for the First Time Buyer ISA. The Lifetime ISA is open now, and the bonus starts compounding sooner. If you are over 40, the Lifetime ISA is not available, so the First Time Buyer ISA will be the dedicated option when it launches.
What to Do Now
- If you are 18 to 39 and saving for a first home, open a Lifetime ISA before you turn 40. You can open it with a small amount and add more later.
- Do not close a Lifetime ISA to wait for the First Time Buyer ISA. The new account does not open until 2029.
- Check the £450,000 property cap in your area. In London and the South East, that cap can matter.
- Keep your deposit in cash if you are buying within five years. Investments can fall just before you need the money.
- Use your £20,000 ISA allowance across accounts, but remember the one-LISA-or-FTB-ISA rule in each tax year.
Use the deposit guide to build the monthly plan, and the first-time buyer guide for the purchase process.
First Time Buyer ISA FAQs
What is the First Time Buyer ISA?
+
The First Time Buyer ISA is a new savings account for first-time buyers, due to launch on 6 April 2029. You can save up to £4,000 a year and receive a 25% government bonus when you buy your first home, capped at £20,000 over the life of the account. The home must cost £450,000 or less.
Is the First Time Buyer ISA available now?
+
No. It launches on 6 April 2029. The Lifetime ISA is still open and unchanged for new savers who meet the age rules.
What is the difference between the First Time Buyer ISA and the Lifetime ISA?
+
The Lifetime ISA is open to people aged 18 to 39, pays a 25% bonus each year up to £1,000, and charges 25% if you withdraw for a non-qualifying reason. The First Time Buyer ISA has no upper age limit, pays the bonus when you buy, has no withdrawal charge, and caps the bonus at £20,000 over the life of the account.
Can I have both a Lifetime ISA and a First Time Buyer ISA?
+
You can hold both, but you can only pay into one of them in the same tax year. Both count towards your £20,000 annual ISA allowance. If you already have a Lifetime ISA, you do not need to close it.
What happens to my Lifetime ISA in 2029?
+
Existing Lifetime ISAs stay open. You can keep saving into one, use it for a first home or retirement, or leave it invested. The First Time Buyer ISA is designed to replace the Lifetime ISA over time, but the Lifetime ISA is not being closed.
What changed for the Lifetime ISA in October 2026?
+
From 29 October 2026, if you use Lifetime ISA money to buy a home above £450,000, you can withdraw it and get back at least what you paid in. The old 25% charge no longer takes part of your own savings in that situation. You still lose the government bonus.
Which is better for a house deposit?
+
If you are under 40 and buying before April 2029, the Lifetime ISA is usually the better choice because the bonus is paid into the account each year and can grow. If you are over 40, not sure when you will buy, or want no withdrawal charge, the First Time Buyer ISA may suit you better when it launches.
What is the maximum bonus?
+
The Lifetime ISA pays up to £1,000 a year until age 50, so the lifetime maximum is around £32,000. The First Time Buyer ISA caps the bonus at £20,000 over the life of the account. The First Time Buyer ISA has a lower cap, but no age limit and no withdrawal charge.
Can I transfer a Help to Buy ISA?
+
Yes. Help to Buy ISA holders will be able to transfer into a First Time Buyer ISA between 6 April 2029 and 1 December 2030, when the Help to Buy ISA is due to close. Check the transfer rules before you move the money.
Is the First Time Buyer ISA the same as the new starter ISA?
+
No. The starter ISA is a separate proposal for first-time investors. The government has not published the full details. The First Time Buyer ISA is specifically for buying a first home.
Plan Your Deposit Around the Right ISA
Compare the accounts, the bonus timing and the property cap before you commit.
Read the Complete ISA GuideSources: GOV.UK First Time Buyer ISA consultation and Budget 2026, MoneyHelper, Deloitte Budget 2026 analysis. The First Time Buyer ISA is not open yet. Check GOV.UK for the final rules.
Related reading
Complete ISA Guide
All the ISA types, the £20,000 allowance and how to split it.
How to Save for a House Deposit
Build the deposit with a monthly plan and the right account.
First-Time Buyer Guide
Deposits, mortgage approval, fees and the buying timeline.
Your First Home Scheme
The new 2.5% deposit scheme and how the equity loan works.
Written by Darren
Founder & editor at Money Meister. Writes and reviews UK tax, mortgage, and budgeting guidance from primary sources (GOV.UK, HMRC, ONS).
Reviewed against current HMRC, FCA, ONS and Ofgem guidance before publication. How we research and review.